Final solution to the problem of relating a true copula to an imprecise copula

In this paper we solve in the negative the problem proposed in this journal (I. Montes et al., Sklar's theorem in an imprecise setting, Fuzzy Sets and Systems, 278 (2015), 48-66) whether an order interval defined by an imprecise copula contains a copula. Namely, if $\mathcal{C}$ is a nonempty set of copulas, then $\underline{C} = \inf\{C\}_{C\in\mathcal{C}}$ and $\overline{C}= \sup\{C\}_{C\in\mathcal{C}}$ are quasi-copulas and the pair $(\underline{C},\overline{C})$ is an imprecise copula according to the definition introduced in the cited paper, following the ideas of $p$-boxes. We show that there is an imprecise copula $(A,B)$ in this sense such that there is no copula $C$ whatsoever satisfying $A \leqslant C\leqslant B$. So, it is questionable whether the proposed definition of the imprecise copula is in accordance with the intentions of the initiators. Our methods may be of independent interest: We upgrade the ideas of Dibala et al. (Defects and transformations of quasi-copulas, Kybernetika, 52 (2016), 848-865) where possibly negative volumes of quasi-copulas as defects from being copulas were studied.Comment: 20 pages; added Conclusion, added some clarifications in proofs, added some explanations at the beginning of each section, corrected typos, results remain the sam

More on restricted canonical correlations

AbstractThe problem of the first canonical correlation between two random vectors subject to some natural constraints is treated in the paper. The problem is usually referred to as restricted canonical correlation. A new approach to solving the problem is given by translating it into a generalized eigenvalue problem with an n×n real symmetric matrix A and a positive definite matrix B of the same size

The solution of the Loewy-Radwan conjecture

A seminal result of Gerstenhaber gives the maximal dimension of a linear space of nilpotent matrices. It also exhibits the structure of this space where the maximal dimension is attained. Extensions of this result in the direction of linear spaces of matrices with a bounded number of eigenvalues have been studied. In this paper, we answer perhaps the most general problem of the kind as proposed by Loewy and Radwan by solving their conjecture in the positive. We give the dimension of a maximal linear space of $n\times n$ matrices with no more than $k<n$ eigenvalues. We also exhibit the structure of the space where this dimension is attained

A full scale Sklar's theorem in the imprecise setting

In this paper we present a surprisingly general extension of the main result of a paper that appeared in this journal: I. Montes et al., Sklar's theorem in an imprecise setting, Fuzzy Sets and Systems, 278 (2015), 48--66. The main tools we develop in order to do so are: (1) a theory on quasi-distributions based on an idea presented in a paper by R. Nelsen with collaborators; (2) starting from what is called (bivariate) $p$-box in the above mentioned paper we propose some new techniques based on what we call restricted (bivariate) $p$-box; and (3) a substantial extension of a theory on coherent imprecise copulas developed by M. Omladi\v{c} and N. Stopar in a previous paper in order to handle coherence of restricted (bivariate) $p$-boxes. A side result of ours of possibly even greater importance is the following: Every bivariate distribution whether obtained on a usual $\sigma$-additive probability space or on an additive space can be obtained as a copula of its margins meaning that its possible extraordinariness depends solely on its margins. This might indicate that copulas are a stronger probability concept than probability itself.Comment: 16 pages, minor change

Constructing copulas from shock models with imprecise distributions

The omnipotence of copulas when modeling dependence given marg\-inal distributions in a multivariate stochastic situation is assured by the Sklar's theorem. Montes et al.\ (2015) suggest the notion of what they call an \emph{imprecise copula} that brings some of its power in bivariate case to the imprecise setting. When there is imprecision about the marginals, one can model the available information by means of $p$-boxes, that are pairs of ordered distribution functions. By analogy they introduce pairs of bivariate functions satisfying certain conditions. In this paper we introduce the imprecise versions of some classes of copulas emerging from shock models that are important in applications. The so obtained pairs of functions are not only imprecise copulas but satisfy an even stronger condition. The fact that this condition really is stronger is shown in Omladi\v{c} and Stopar (2019) thus raising the importance of our results. The main technical difficulty in developing our imprecise copulas lies in introducing an appropriate stochastic order on these bivariate objects

On approximate commutativity of spaces of matrices

The maximal dimension of commutative subspaces of $M_n(\mathbb{C})$ is known. So is the structure of such a subspace when the maximal dimension is achieved. We consider extensions of these results and ask the following natural questions: If $V$ is a subspace of $M_n(\mathbb{C})$ and $k$ is an integer less than $n$, such that for every pair $A$ and $B$ of members of $V$, the rank of the commutator $AB - BA$ is at most $k$, then how large can the dimension of $V$ be? If this maximum is achieved, can we determine the structure of $V$? We answer the first question. We also propose a conjecture on the second question which implies, in particular, that such a subspace $V$ has to be an algebra, just as in the known case of $k = 0$. We prove the proposed structure of $V$ if it is already assumed to be an algebra.Comment: 17 page

Relation between non-exchangeability and measures of concordance of copulas

An investigation is presented of how a comprehensive choice of five most important measures of concordance (namely Spearman's rho, Kendall's tau, Gini's gamma, Blomqvist's beta, and their weaker counterpart Spearman's footrule) relate to non-exchangeability, i.e., asymmetry on copulas. Besides these results, the method proposed also seems to be new and may serve as a raw model for exploration of the relationship between a specific property of a copula and some of its measures of dependence structure, or perhaps the relationship between various measures of dependence structure themselves.Comment: 27 pages, 11 figure